When the Pain Doesn't Match the Problem
Understanding Referred Pain and the Body's Remarkable Design
Arukah Insider | October 22, 2026
Pain doesn't always tell its entire story in one place
Living with pain can be exhausting. Not just physically, but mentally and emotionally. When discomfort becomes part of everyday life, it can begin influencing how you move, how you sleep, what activities you avoid, and even how much you trust your own body. Perhaps you've sought treatment, experienced temporary relief, and found yourself right back where you started. Maybe you've been told everything looks normal, yet you know something doesn't feel right.
Your pain is real. But understanding why you're experiencing it sometimes requires looking beyond the place that hurts. One of the things I've learned through years of working with the human body is that pain calls for more than our attention. It calls for our curiosity, our understanding, and a willingness to look beyond what we first see. Our bodies are remarkably complex. Muscles, joints, connective tissues, and the nervous system continually communicate and adapt to the demands placed upon them.
And sometimes, the location where we experience pain isn't where the problem begins.

When the source of pain isn't where we feel it
Imagine you've been experiencing an aching, pulling sensation between your shoulder blades. Naturally, you assume something is wrong with the muscles in your upper back. Perhaps you've tried stretching, applying heat, or having someone massage that uncomfortable area. But the discomfort keeps returning.
What if part of the problem isn't coming from your back at all? What if the muscles along the front of your chest are influencing how your shoulder blade moves? The pectoralis minor, for example, attaches directly to the scapula, or shoulder blade. Changes in its flexibility, activity, or resting position can influence shoulder mechanics and how surrounding muscles work together.
In certain situations, this can contribute to discomfort in the muscles along the upper back. This is an example of how one area of the body can influence another through biomechanics. But there's another fascinating relationship worth understanding: referred pain.

Your nervous system: More than a messenger
Referred pain occurs when discomfort is experienced somewhere other than the tissue or structure contributing to it. Our nervous system is constantly gathering information. Sensory nerves carry information from muscles, joints, skin, and other tissues toward the spinal cord and brain. The central nervous system processes that information, while motor pathways help coordinate the body's responses.
However, pain isn't always a precise map of where tissue irritation or injury is occurring. Some sensory pathways converge within the spinal cord. Because information from different structures may be processed through overlapping neural circuits, the nervous system can sometimes interpret pain as coming from a location different from its source. Think about accidentally hitting your funny bone.
That unmistakable sensation traveling from your elbow toward your fingers happens because you've irritated the ulnar nerve. Technically, this is nerve-related radiating sensation rather than classic referred pain. But it illustrates something important: where we experience a sensation doesn't always match where the irritation occurred. Muscles can also produce recognizable patterns of referred discomfort.
Drs. Janet Travell and David Simons extensively documented these patterns in their work on myofascial pain and trigger points. For example, certain muscles in the neck, including the scalenes, may produce discomfort extending toward the shoulder, chest, or upper back. These patterns aren't exact maps, and they cannot independently identify the source of someone's pain. But they can provide valuable clues when considered alongside medical history, movement, symptoms, and physical examination.
This is why understanding anatomy matters.
The painful area is important, but it may be only one part of a much larger conversation happening within the body.
Listening to the whole story
When someone comes into my office, I want to understand more than where they're hurting. I want to know how the discomfort began. Was there an injury? A surgery? An accident several years ago?
Does the pain change with movement? Does it worsen during certain activities? Have you begun avoiding movements because you're afraid of aggravating something? And perhaps just as importantly, how has this pain affected your everyday life? These questions aren't simply conversation.
They're part of understanding the relationships between your body's structures, your movement patterns, your nervous system, and your experiences. Sometimes a muscle is working harder because another area isn't moving or functioning as efficiently. Sometimes the nervous system has become more sensitive following an injury or prolonged discomfort.
And sometimes the symptoms suggest something that requires further medical evaluation. We can't assume every painful muscle contains a trigger point or that every symptom can be resolved through bodywork.
Good care begins with listening, continues through careful assessment, and remains willing to change direction when new information emerges.

Understanding pain can change how we respond to it
There's another important part of pain that we don't always discuss. Our nervous system doesn't respond to physical sensations in isolation. Previous injuries, expectations, emotions, stress, and our perception of safety can influence how pain is experienced.
If you've experienced a significant injury, certain sensations may understandably create concern, especially when they remind you of what happened before. That doesn't mean the pain is imaginary. It means your nervous system is doing something remarkably complex: interpreting information while considering both your current condition and previous experiences.
During therapeutic bodywork, I sometimes encounter this when working with a sensitive muscle. A client may suddenly notice discomfort traveling toward an area where they've previously experienced pain. Their breathing changes. Their body begins guarding. They become concerned that something is wrong.
This is where education, communication, and careful observation become especially important. I may explain the referral pattern, show the muscle on an anatomical chart, and help them understand why that sensation might be occurring. Then we work together.
Sometimes that means maintaining gentle-to-moderate, tolerable pressure while practicing diaphragmatic breathing. Sometimes it means adjusting the pressure, changing techniques, or stopping altogether. I may encourage someone to imagine a muscle gradually softening, much like a piece of Laffy Taffy becoming more pliable in the warmth.
The imagery isn't physically melting the muscle. It's a way of directing attention and encouraging relaxation. Occasionally, the referred discomfort becomes less intense or more localized as the person settles into the treatment. That response can be useful information, although it doesn't necessarily mean we've identified or corrected the original source of pain.
What matters is that the person understands what's happening and remains an active participant.
Pain may be part of the treatment conversation, but it should never take away your voice or your ability to make decisions about your care.
Compassion and participation belong together
When you've been hurting for a long time, it's understandable to want someone to make the discomfort disappear. But meaningful progress often involves more than temporarily reducing symptoms. It may require improving mobility, developing strength, addressing movement habits, or gradually rebuilding confidence in activities that have become uncomfortable.
Sometimes that work is challenging. It requires patience, consistency, and a willingness to participate in the process. Compassion doesn't mean avoiding every challenge. It means recognizing the difficulty of someone's experience while helping them find a reasonable path forward.
My responsibility is to listen, educate, observe, and work within my professional scope. Your responsibility isn't to push through everything or ignore what your body is communicating. Instead, we learn to recognize those signals together. There may be setbacks. There may be discoveries that change our approach. And there may be times when another healthcare professional is better equipped to investigate a particular concern.
That's part of caring for the whole person.
Fearfully and wonderfully made
One of the things I find most remarkable about the human body is how thoughtfully and intricately its systems work together. Our muscles don't operate independently of our nervous system. Our movement isn't separate from our physical limitations. And our experience of pain isn't entirely disconnected from our history, emotions, or circumstances. We are whole beings.
Psalm 139:14 reminds us: “I am fearfully and wonderfully made.” I think about that often when considering the remarkable complexity of the human body.
God created us with an extraordinary capacity to respond, adapt, protect, and learn. Sometimes those protective responses become less helpful over time. Muscles may develop compensatory patterns. Movement may become guarded. The nervous system may remain particularly sensitive even after an initial injury has healed. Being wonderfully made doesn't mean our bodies are without limitations.
It means we can approach those limitations with respect, curiosity, and an appreciation for how intricately everything is connected. And perhaps that understanding changes how we approach pain. Instead of seeing our bodies as something working against us, we can begin asking what they're communicating and what they may need.
Sometimes the answer involves rest. Sometimes movement, strengthening, or changing familiar habits. Sometimes it requires additional medical care. And sometimes it begins with understanding that the place where we hurt isn't necessarily where the entire story begins.
Your pain matters. Your body is worth understanding. And your story matters.

Carrie Kooyenga
PTA, LMT
Arukah Wellness & Assisting



Comments