Why Does My Body Hold So Much Tension?
Understanding Muscle Guarding and Protective Responses
Have you ever settled into bed at the end of a long day, only to notice your shoulders are still up by your ears? It’s as if your body is standing guard, even when the battle is long over. In this article, we’ll uncover why that happens, how your body’s protective instincts come into play, and how you can gently invite it to stand down.
In our October letters, we explored two important ideas: pain is not always a measurement of damage, and the place that hurts may not tell the whole story. There is another question that naturally follows. If the body is designed to protect us, what happens when its protective responses become familiar—even after circumstances change?

When the Body Stands Guard
That tension you feel may reflect a protective response your body has used before. When pain, strain, or uncertainty changes how we move, the nervous system can adjust muscle activity to help stabilize an area or limit a movement that feels uncomfortable. This is one way to understand muscle guarding. It is not a conscious decision, and it does not always mean an injury is happening right now.
Think about how you move after twisting an ankle. You may shorten your stride, shift your weight, or tighten muscles around the joint without deliberately planning any of it. Such adjustments can be useful while an injury heals. But not every adaptation remains useful indefinitely, and the sensation of tightness does not prove that a muscle is continuously contracting.
There is an important difference between feeling tight and measuring a muscle that is actively contracting. People may describe stiffness, pulling, pressure, or restricted movement as “tension,” yet these sensations can arise from several sources. A muscle can feel tight without being unusually short, and pain can make ordinary movement feel less available. Guarding is one possible explanation—not a diagnosis we can make from a sensation alone.
I often think about the small things people do without realizing it. Someone may be describing a difficult week while their shoulders slowly rise. Another person may hold their breath when they anticipate an uncomfortable movement. When I bring attention to it, the response is sometimes surprise: ‘I didn't even know I was doing that.’ Awareness doesn't diagnose the cause, but it gives us something useful to explore together.
What the Science Adds
Pain and movement are linked through a network involving sensory receptors, the spinal cord, the brain, and the nerves that activate muscles. Pain can change the timing and distribution of muscle activity. Some muscles may work harder, others may work less, and movement may become less varied. The response differs across people and situations.
Here is the physiology in everyday terms. Sensory receptors in muscles, joints, and other tissues provide information about position, movement, and potentially harmful stimulation. The spinal cord processes some of that information and participates in rapid reflex responses. The brain integrates sensory input with context, previous experience, and the task at hand. Motor pathways then influence which muscle fibers are recruited, when they activate, and how much force is produced. This is a coordinated system, not a single alarm switch.

Researchers Paul Hodges and Kylie Tucker proposed that pain-related adaptations can involve a “redistribution of activity within and between muscles.”[1] In their model, altered recruitment and movement may protect a painful region in the short term, but the consequences can become less helpful when movement variety decreases or loads shift over time. This is a proposed framework supported by experimental observations, not proof that every tense muscle is protecting against a past event.
This is where I want to be careful with our language. A body can learn patterns, but we cannot look at a tight shoulder and conclude that a person has unresolved trauma. There may be an old injury, a repetitive job, a current medical condition, a stressful season, or several influences at once. Sometimes there is no single explanation. The goal is not to assign a story to someone's muscles; it is to ask better questions.
Why Might Tension Continue?
Sometimes the original strain has improved, but a person still moves cautiously. Perhaps they expect a particular movement to hurt. Perhaps their work repeatedly demands the same posture, or sleep has been poor and recovery incomplete. Ongoing pain, limited movement variety, stress, and underlying medical conditions can all contribute to how tension is experienced. What feels like one simple problem may actually have several influences.
Our nervous systems learn from experience. If a movement has been painful repeatedly, we may anticipate discomfort and alter our movement before pain even occurs. This is not proof that the pain is imaginary. It is evidence that movement, sensation, memory, and expectation interact. And importantly, an old protective behavior does not necessarily mean there is a current danger.
Imagine reaching for something on a high shelf after an earlier shoulder injury. Long after the initial injury has improved, you might raise the entire shoulder girdle, hold your breath, or turn your trunk rather than moving the arm as freely as before. That adjustment may happen before you consciously notice it. It is one example of a learned strategy that deserves curiosity rather than blame. A similar pattern can emerge with repeated physical work or simply when a task feels demanding; it does not automatically indicate trauma.
Stress Is Physical, Too
When life demands our attention, our bodies may become more alert. Breathing can grow shallow or rapid, jaw muscles may clench, and shoulders may rise. The autonomic nervous system participates in these changes, but it is not an on-off switch with one setting for danger and another for safety. Physical workload, emotional strain, illness, medications, and sleep can all affect the picture.
Consider the person who drives home after a difficult shift and realizes their hands have been gripping the steering wheel, their jaw has been set, and their breathing has barely changed all afternoon. There may be no immediate danger in the driveway. Still, the day’s demands can influence the way they carry themselves into the evening. For some people, past stressful experiences also shape expectations and habits. We should not assume that muscle tension reveals a hidden trauma history; the same physical pattern can have many explanations.
For someone living with persistent discomfort, being told to “just relax” can feel frustrating. Relaxation is not always achieved by deciding to loosen a muscle. The more useful question may be: What is contributing to this pattern, and what would help this person feel supported enough to move, breathe, and recover differently?
Why Stretching or Massage May Not Be the Entire Answer
Think about a person whose neck feels better after a session but becomes uncomfortable again after another week of long drives, short sleep, and hours at a desk. That doesn't automatically mean the session failed. It may mean relief was one useful part of a bigger plan. Perhaps we need to look at work breaks, strength and endurance, sleep, movement confidence, or whether a medical assessment is appropriate. Sometimes I can help with part of that plan. Sometimes another professional is needed. Good care makes room for both.
I do not want clients to become dependent on someone else to interpret every sensation. I want them to understand what we are noticing and to participate in deciding what comes next. Sometimes the right response is to move. Sometimes it is to pause. Sometimes it is to investigate further.
Stretching and therapeutic bodywork may provide meaningful relief, improve comfort, or make movement feel easier. Yet temporary relief does not automatically identify the cause of the tension. If a person returns to the same demanding workload, limited sleep, or movement strategy, the sensation may return. This is not a failure of the treatment or of the person. It is a reminder to consider the whole picture.
At Arukah, this is why we look beyond the single place that hurts. We consider how a person moves, what their day asks of their body, how symptoms change, and which approaches are appropriate within their care plan. Sometimes manual therapy is useful. Sometimes education, graded movement, strength, pacing, or further medical evaluation is equally important.
A thoughtful plan may begin with questions rather than techniques: When does the tension appear? What makes it easier or harder? Does it change with rest, walking, breathing, work, or sleep? Is the person avoiding a movement because of a previous painful experience? These observations help us decide when hands-on care may support comfort and when progressive movement, strengthening, pacing, or referral for medical assessment is the more important next step. Relief is meaningful, but restoring choice and confidence in movement matters, too.
Remember the person from the beginning of this letter—the one who finally lies down and discovers their shoulders are still up by their ears? Instead of treating that moment as another failure to relax, what if we treated it as a chance to notice? Not every sensation needs to be fixed immediately. Sometimes the first helpful step is simply recognizing what we are doing.
A Gentle Practice Before Bed
We've spent some time exploring why our bodies develop protective patterns, how our nervous systems respond to our experiences, and why certain muscles may continue working long after the original demand has passed.
But understanding why something happens is only part of the conversation. The next question is, what can we do with that understanding? Sometimes we become so accustomed to the way we hold ourselves that we don't even recognize the effort anymore. Our shoulders stay elevated, our jaws remain clenched, and our breathing becomes shallow as we move from one responsibility to the next. And then bedtime comes. The house grows quiet. The demands of the day begin to settle. Yet our bodies don't always follow quite so quickly.
So rather than asking you to simply relax, I'd like to invite you to experience something with me. Nothing complicated. Nothing you need to accomplish. Just a few intentional minutes to become curious about what your body might be doing.

Let's begin.
Find a comfortable place to sit or lie down. Maybe you're already in bed, or perhaps you're sitting in your favorite chair. Allow yourself to settle into whatever position feels most comfortable and supported.
If you'd like, close your eyes. Or simply soften your gaze and look around the room. Take a moment to notice what's around you. The familiar walls. The quiet sounds. The surface supporting you. You don't have to change anything just yet.
Let's begin by listening.
Bring your attention to your forehead. Are you holding tension there? Is your brow furrowed, even though the day is coming to an end?
Now notice your jaw. Are your teeth resting together? Are you clenching without realizing it? If it's comfortable, allow a little space between your teeth.
Let your attention travel down toward your neck and shoulders. Remember those shoulders we talked about earlier? The ones that somehow find their way up toward your ears? Where are they right now?
Perhaps they're already resting comfortably. Or maybe they're still working, still holding, still preparing for whatever might come next. You don't have to force them down. Just notice where they are.
Continue slowly through your arms and hands. Are your fingers curled tightly? Are you gripping the blanket or holding your hands in little fists?
Now notice your abdomen, hips, and legs. Is there somewhere you're bracing? Somewhere you're working a little harder than you realized? And here's something I want you to remember: you don't have to fix everything you notice. Sometimes becoming aware of a pattern is the first meaningful step toward changing it.
Now, let's bring our attention to breathing. If it's comfortable, place one hand along your lower ribs or over your abdomen. Take an easy breath in through your nose, allowing your lower ribs and abdomen to gently expand. Then let that breath leave without pushing it out.
Try that again. A comfortable breath in. And an easy breath out. There's no need to take the biggest breath you can manage. We're not trying to force your body into relaxation. We're simply giving it an opportunity to breathe without so much effort.
Notice whether your shoulders want to rise as you inhale. If they do, see whether you can allow a little more movement through your lower ribs instead. Take a few more breaths at your own pace. If breathing this way feels uncomfortable or makes you lightheaded, return to your usual breathing. There's no need to push through.
Before we finish, let's check in one more time.
How does your jaw feel now? What about your shoulders? Are your hands resting a little differently? Maybe something has softened. Maybe nothing feels particularly different tonight. That's okay.
The purpose of this practice isn't to make every muscle relax on command. It's to begin recognizing the patterns you carry throughout the day and to give yourself opportunities to respond differently. If paying attention to sensations inside your body feels uncomfortable or unsettling, you can always return your attention to the room. Notice the colors around you, listen to a familiar sound, or feel your feet against the floor. You can skip any part of this exercise.
As you prepare for sleep, consider one small thing that might help you settle. Perhaps you dim the lights, set your phone aside, adjust your pillow, or gently move your shoulders before lying down. Nothing complicated. Nothing that needs to be perfect. Just a few intentional moments of listening, breathing, and caring for the body that has carried you through another day.
And tomorrow? We practice again. Not because we've failed to relax today, but because learning new patterns often takes time, repetition, and patience.
Perhaps as you worked through that practice, you discovered tension you hadn't even realized you were carrying. Or perhaps you noticed very little change. Both experiences can teach us something. Our bodies don't always respond immediately simply because we've decided it's time to rest. And learning to recognize familiar patterns doesn't mean we can change them all in a single evening. Sometimes progress begins with something much quieter. Awareness. Patience. A willingness to listen rather than immediately demanding a different response.
And as I think about that, I'm reminded that learning to rest isn't always just a physical conversation. Sometimes it's a personal one. Because there are things we carry in our bodies, and there are things we carry in our hearts. And that brings me to something my faith has taught me about rest.
A Reflection on Rest
There is a difference between stopping our activity and truly experiencing rest. We can lie down while our thoughts continue racing, while our shoulders remain lifted, or while our bodies anticipate tomorrow’s demands. Learning to recognize those patterns can be an act of patient stewardship rather than another task to perform perfectly.
In Matthew 11:28, Jesus says, “Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.” This invitation speaks to a deeper kind of rest. It is not a promise that faith will immediately resolve muscle pain, and ongoing symptoms are not evidence of inadequate trust. But it reminds us that we do not have to carry every burden as though our strength alone must be enough.
Our bodies are wonderfully made, capable of adapting, protecting, and learning. Sometimes healing involves understanding why a response began. Sometimes it involves gently practicing a new way forward. And sometimes it begins with giving ourselves permission to notice what we have been carrying—with patience, sound care, and hope.

This is Arukah
Heal & Restore
-Carrie
REFERENCES
1. Hodges, P. W., & Tucker, K. (2011). Moving differently in pain: A new theory to explain the adaptation to pain. Pain, 152(3 Suppl), S90–S98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pain.2010.10.020
2. Hodges, P. W. (2011). Pain and motor control: From the laboratory to rehabilitation. Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, 21(2), 220–228. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jelekin.2011.01.002
3. International Association for the Study of Pain. (2021). Preventing Pain: An Introduction. https://www.iasp-pain.org/resources/fact-sheets/preventing-pain-an-introduction/
4. Bervoets, D. C., et al. (2015). Massage therapy has short-term benefits for people with common musculoskeletal disorders compared to no treatment: A systematic review. Journal of Physiotherapy, 61, 106–116. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26093806/
5. Hodges, P. W., & Smeets, R. J. (2015). Interaction between pain, movement, and physical activity: Short-term benefits, long-term consequences, and targets for treatment. The Clinical Journal of Pain, 31(2), 97–107. https://doi.org/10.1097/AJP.0000000000000098




Comments